Two very different stories that I chanced upon today. Both have to do with food. And both have to do with death. Both have to do with abject Government callousness, and the complete disregard for regulatory norms by those who control the area.
The first is a link that i followed from the Milli Gazette on deaths due to starvation in Murshidabad, in West Bengal. The West Bengal Government website describes the area as:
The place of the Nawabs. Natural tradition of culture and education are still felt in the district. Agriculture is the main activity. Sericulture and mango are the two cash crops in addition. Murshidabad silk is a name by itself, which adds to the income of the district to a great extent.
It is in this very same Murshidabad – in a non descript place called Jalnagi – that people are dying of hunger. How is it possible in a nation which has an agricultural surplus, you may ask? And rightly so. The Milli Gazette reports:
near-starvation conditions in Jalangi have been caused by the changing course of the river Padma, which has destroyed farmlands, leading to numerous deaths and rendering hundreds of people to destitution, forcing them to beg or else to migrate outside the region in search of survival opportunities. Stark poverty has reduced many people to surviving on roots and leaves, leading to widespread disease and malnutrition. To make matters worse, apathetic local and state administrations are allowing food supplies to rot in godowns while a majority of the affected people are not even issued below-poverty-line ration cards. Poverty eradication programmes are not being properly implemented and people working under the Food For Work programme remain unpaid for long periods despite funds having been released to the local authorities. People complain that money is being deducted from the paltry wages that they are entitled to under the poverty eradication programmes in order to fund local CPI (M) party activities . It is also alleged that beneficiaries of these programmes are selected on the basis of party affiliation.
You can read the full report here.
Maybe the Left Front should stop screaming about disinvestment and focus on how Government Schemes (and there are a lot of ‘good’ schemes that the Government has) can be effectively utilised to help the poor.
The Central Government needs to come down heavily on any state government that links welfare schemes to party affiliation, support or membership. If we can feel outraged about Tsunami aid – provided by American missionaries – being linked to religion, we should feel doubly outraged by our own elected representatives behaving like a bunch of blackmailing thugs.
The second story is from another part of India, equally fertile as Bengal. The bread basket to the nation. Punjab. CSE – the organisation that blew the whistle on Coke and Pepsi being contaminated with pesticides – reports that farmers in Punjab have 15 to 605 times the acceptable amounts of pesticide in their blood. And, no one knows what kind of long term effects this contamination will have. CSE’s press release says :
The levels of certain persistent organochlorine pesticides (OCs) in the samples were astounding: 15-605 times higher than those found in blood samples of people in the US, tested by the US Centre for Disease Control and Prevention in its report of 2003. Levels of lindane, a restricted pesticide in India, were 605 times higher than those found in the US population. Similarly, the levels of DDT were 188 times higher. The CSE study detected hexachlorocyclohexane (HCH) in all the blood samples, and DDT in 95 per cent of the samples
The full report is here.
Is life so cheap in our country that at one end we let people die of hunger – while food rots in warehouses, and at the other end – people growing food using “productivity enhancers” end up dying of slow poisoning.
Neither story is probably going to be picked up by mainstream media. Afterall, who is interested in a bunch of poor people dying?
The MSM did run this story, as I remember it in a few websites, and atleast a couple of newspapers. It is true that many of them didn’t follow-up with specials or investigative stories to give greater publicity.
But, the initial story itself probably met with apathy, and didn’t hold the interest of the readers much. So, I think the lack of real outrage reflects more on the general reader population, than about the mainstream media.
I’m not surprised. It is always a case of, ‘if it doesn’t hurt me today, who cares’. And, when it does come back to hurt me, it will be like, ‘what a terrible Govt. this is, what a terrible blah, blah….’
As they say about many things, we all get what we deserve. Always.
Hi subra. nice to see you on POV.
i am not sure about the apathy of readers. if my headline screamed about people dying of hunger – 58 years after independence – and there was a sense of outrage about it, it probably would catch attention. tucking away the story with a bland headline will not get it noticed.
also, these kind of stories are usually de humanised. they become more a case of spouting statistics and policy pitfalls. however, if you give the story a human face – mala dies of hunger – it becomes more real.
i think Stalin got it right when he said – when one person dies it is a tragedy, when millions die it is statistics.
Harini
You have written as if you knew me from before ? Do you ? Or, are you mistaking me for somoene else of the same name….?
This “headline screaming” is a visual illusion that we conjure up in our minds. In truth, print headlines scream only if I have my ears and mind tuned to that topic. If I wasn’t interested in the original topic, I wouldn’t care, no matter how big or bold or colorful the headline is.
With that being said, the media is only giving us stuff in the way they are giving it, because that is what we look at. Even the media is a for-profit business, and it is in the business to make money. So, their behaviour is conditioned by what their audience wants to read / see / hear. (Rare is an MSM that conditions readers to what it gives)
A pesticide related death story doesn’t win them that many eyeballs, and consequently, money. So, we could blame the media for being opportunistic. But that is no more a crime, than being in a for-profit business.
However, the missing eyeballs are what are the root cause of the problem. And, I am not indicting them. Life here is one long, rough journey for most of us common folks. The general feeling is “what can I do ?”. The apathy comes from there. It is a truly pathetic attitude, (and I include myself in that list), but that is the reality. We don’t have an enabling and empowering justice and police system conducive for mass action in such cases. Without that, popular perceptions can never drive action on such matters.
hi subra. neither.
i was merely extending courtsies to someone who was commentign for the first time on my site!
Subra……..you are right ….the left front govt. are busy with dirty politics and innovating new booth-capturing techniques……so…..
Subra……..you are right ….the left front govt. are busy with dirty politics and innovating new booth-capturing techniques……so…..