Posts Tagged ‘Politics’

27
Oct

Blood on their Hands…with Glee

   Posted by: gargi    in India

You must have been on moon not to have not heard and be struck by Tehelka’s expose on the Gujarat riots, in the words of the men who committed murder, rape, and carnage.

THERE WAS no spontaneity to what happened in Gujarat post- Godhra. This was no uncontrived, unplanned, unprompted communal violence. This was a pogrom. This was genocide.

In a series of articles, the magazine strips away the masks to reveal the glee and joy at carnage. This goes beyond a pogrom - it becomes a pogrom led by people who enjoy violence and perpetuating it. In addition to the stories, read the diary of Ashish Khetan, the man who possibly put his life at risk, in carrying out this report. Read it here

If you have seen Rakesh Sharma’s Final Solution or read Dionne Bunsha’s Scarred : Experiments with Violence in Gujarat- the contents expose will not come as a surprise, unless you are the BJP.But, what is shocking is the systematic and co-ordinated manner in which psychopaths practiced their craft.

….local BJP MLA Mayaben Kodnani, who is also a doctor…..drove around Naroda all through the day, urging the mob to hunt Muslims down and kill them. Kodnani’s trusted lieutenant, BJP member Bipin Panchal, was also present with his own small band of followers, armed to the teeth. All through the massacre, Bajrangi and VHP state general secretary Jaideep Patel were on the phone with each other. Bajrangi did not reveal whether Patel was also involved in the planning. However, he did say that the death toll was being communicated to Patel at regular intervals.

 

Be very afraid, say Tarun Tejpal - editor in chief of Tehelka, in his foreword to one of the most chilling journalistic pieces that I have ever seen and heard. And co-ordinated and planned manner in which the saffron brigade organised themselves, and the casualness with which they committed murder, and the utter lack of remorse that they show on camera - does more than scare you, it terrifies you.

Anil Patel, the VHP vibhag pramukh (departmental chief), was among the key planners of the carnage here. He told TEHELKA that after the Sabarmati incident, he had taken a vow to kill at least 500 Muslims, failing which he would relinquish the VHP office he was holding. “Our war cry was ‘Lock the door from outside and burn the Muslims from the inside’,” Patel told TEHELKA.

 

Read the transcript of Baba Bajrangi and you will be more than afraid, you are most likely to end up throwing up what ever is in your stomach.

TEHELKA: Tell us how it was all done… revolvers… cylinders… Bajrangi: The cylinders were theirs [the Muslims’]… Whichever house we entered, we just grabbed the cylinder and fired at it, and, dhadak, they exploded… We had guns in any case… I can’t tell you what a good time it was… But four of our activists died in it… No hearing took place even in that… TEHELKA: Did you climb to the top of a masjid and tie a pig there? Bajrangi:We rammed an entire tanker into it… the tanker was fully laden… We rammed that tanker inside… TEHELKA: It was a petrol tanker, no? Bajrangi: It was diesel… We drove a whole diesel tanker in and then set [the mosque] on fire… TEHELKA: Meaning, it was the tanker explosion which set Patiya on fire? Bajrangi: In the masjid… TEHELKA: In the masjid… Bajrangi: As for the rest of it, I was in charge at the time… Whatever I wanted to do, I did… TEHELKA: At the pit, was oil… Those people had gathered there… Bajrangi: It was a huge pit… You could enter it from one side but you couldn’t climb out at the other end… They were all there together… They started clinging to each other… Even while they were dying, they told each other, you die too, what are you going to be saved for, you die too… so the number of deaths increased. TEHELKA: Then people poured oil in… Bajrangi: Oil and burning tyres… TEHELKA: Where did the oil come from? Bajrangi: Oh that… We had lots of material with us… we filled lots of jerrycans in advance… From the petrol pump, the night before… Petrol pump owners gave us petrol and diesel for free…

And

Today too I am fighting against Muslims and will continue to do so… I have nothing to do with politics… What I say is this: the VHP is an organisation… a Hindu organisation… Our politics should be limited to killing Muslims, beating them up… TEHELKA: How do you feel after you have killed Muslims… Bajrangi: Maza aata hai na, saheb [I enjoy it]… I came back after I killed them them, called up the home minister and went to sleep… I felt like Rana Pratap, that I had done something like Maharana Pratap… I’d heard stories about him, but that day I did what he did myself.

This is Suresh Richard - a member of the Charra tribe - a recruit to the VHP talking about murder and rape…

Richard: One of our brothers brought a tanker… from Thakar Nagar crossroad…. He’d killed Muslims and brought the tanker. It was put in reverse and the mosque was broken… [It burst] like water out of a fire engine… Petrol was thrown and then it was burnt…

TEHELKA: who brought the tanker? Richard: A brother brought it… TEHELKA: From the VHP… Richard: Not that… He was a Hindu brother… Those who were inside… they were all finished … TEHELKA: It is being said the Chharas also committed rapes… Richard: Now look, one thing is true… bhookhe ghuse to koi na koi to phal khayega, na [when thousands of hungry men go in, they will eat some fruit or the other, no]… Aise bhi, phal ko kuchal ke phek denge [in any case, the fruit are going to be crushed and thrown away]… Look, I’m not telling lies… Mata is before me [gesturing to an image of a deity]… Many Muslim girls were being killed and burnt to death anyway, some people must have helped themselves to the fruit… TEHELKA: There must have been a couple of rapes… Richard: Might even have been more… then there were the rest of our brothers, our Hindu brothers, VHP people and RSS people… Anyone could have helped themselves… who wouldn’t, when there’s fruit?… The more you harm them, the less it is… I really hate them… don’t want to spare them… Look, my wife is sitting here but let me say…the fruit was there so it had to be eaten… I also ate… I also ate… I ate once TEHELKA: Just once? Richard: Just once… then I had to go killing again… [turns to relative Prakash Rathod and talks about the girl he had raped and killed]… That scrap-dealer’s girl, Naseemo… Naseemo that juicy plump one… I got on top… TEHELKA: You got on top of her… Richard: Yes, properly… TEHELKA: She didn’t survive, did she? Richard: No, then I pulped her… Made her into a pickle…

And all of this under the tutelage of the man who is the next great hope for the BJP{/tag]. [tag]Narendra Modi’s party has reacted to it in its typical way — by going into collective denial Not us, conspiracy, The Congress Information Agency (CIA) - while describing Tehelka, politically motivated, etal.. And, while all of it may be true….. the fact remains that the people on camera aren’t secular lackeys or Congress stooges, … they are members of the saffron family gloating about murder and rape.

Isn’t it about time that the full force of the law is brought down on these people, and justice is delivered?

Technorati Tags: Tehelka, , , , Scarred : Experiments with Violence in Gujarat, , ,

Sphere: Related Content

Tags: , , , , ,

22
Oct

Corruption, the Media, and Opinion.

   Posted by: gargi    in India, Media, Print

The NYT has an excellent op-ed on corruption. Specifically, corruption in the context of the Iraq war. Called Suicide is Not Painless (a kind of hat tip to MASH whose theme music was "Suicide is Painless"). It starts with the suicide of a civil servant who could have been indicted for corruption… and then it articulates the level of corruption in Iraq

Set against the epic corruption that has defined the war in Iraq, Mr. Riechers’s tragic tale is but a passing anecdote, his infraction at most a misdemeanor. The $26,788 he received for two months in a non-job doesn’t rise even to a rounding error in the Iraq-Afghanistan money pit. So far some $6 billion worth of contracts are being investigated for waste and fraud, however slowly, by the Pentagon and the Justice Department. That doesn’t include the unaccounted-for piles of cash, some $9 billion in Iraqi funds, that vanished during L. Paul Bremer’s short but disastrous reign in the Green Zone. Yet Mr. Riechers, not the first suicide connected to the war’s corruption scandals, is a window into the culture of the whole debacle. Through his story you can see how America has routinely betrayed the very values of democratic governance that it hoped to export to Iraq. Look deeper and you can see how the wholesale corruption of government contracting sabotaged the crucial mission that might have enabled us to secure the country: the rebuilding of the Iraqi infrastructure, from electricity to hospitals.

Read the entire opinion piece and mourn the absence of this level of incisiveness, articulation and analysis in the Indian News Media - being the largest is not going to be enough… occasionally, just occasionally you also need to be the best.

Technorati Tags:

Sphere: Related Content

Tags: , , , ,

22
Oct

Slimelife…

   Posted by: gargi    in India, Politics

… kind of describes our politicians well, and it describes people of all political persuasion. This from CNN-IBN

"Rahul-Rajiv, Rajiv-Feroz. Until there it’s okay, but then what after that? These Congressmen who abuse Narendra Modi, show us your roots. You are the descendants of Muslims from Junagadh," he said.

The barb on Rahul Gandhi’s origins came after B K Hariprasad had said: "Vote pane ke lie hamesha Soniaji ke bare mai ulta sidha bolne wale Narendra Modi ko main bolna chahata hu ki Sonia Gandhi ka birth certificate ki humko koi zaroorat nahin hai. Janta Sonia Gandhi ko Indira Gandhi ke roop mein dekhti hai. Magar kya Gujarat ke bahar ki janta ko yeh malum hai ki woh (Narendra Modi) kaunsi naali mein paida hua hai? Usko (Narendra Modi) pata nahi hai ki uske baap ka name kya hai, jo Sonia ji ke baare mein baatein karta rehta hai. (I want to tell Narendra Modi — who always targets Sonia Gandhi for want of votes — that we do not need Sonia Gandhi’s birth certificate. Indian people see her as a reincarnation of Indira Gandhi. But do the people outside Gujarat know which gutter Narendra Modi was born in? He does not even know his own father’s name.)"

I don’t like Narendra Modi and his brand of politics. But, this is really not on… If the Congress wants to win votes, it needs to show that is a better party, not a worse party…

Technorati Tags: ,

Sphere: Related Content

Tags: , , , ,

1
Oct

Without Nepotism….

   Posted by: gargi    in And Finally ..., India, Politics

says the NYT:

Without nepotism, Hillary would be running for the president of Vassar. But then, without nepotism, W. would be pumping gas in Midland — and not out of the ground.

i wounder where our leaders would be. Sonia Gandhi would be a housewife, Rajiv Gandhi a pilot, Rahul Gandhi a banker, Rahul Mahajan - behind bars, Supriya Sule a social worker……..and the list continues.

Technorati Tags: , , , ,

Sphere: Related Content

Tags: , ,

18
Apr

Defenders of Indian Culture

   Posted by: gargi    in India, Politics

From today’s Express:

A BJP MP from Gujarat was on Wednesday detained at the Indira Gandhi international airport in New Delhi for allegedly misusing his wife’s passport by taking another woman.Babubhai Katara, who represents Dahod in the Lok Sabha, was detained by immigration officials after they found out that the woman who was travelling with him was one Paramjeet and not his wife Sarada Ben.

It is almost as funny as the BJP minister in charge of "religious affairs & cow protection" from Gujarat who was arrested with copious amounts of liquor . (addendum) - it is no longer funny, what i thought was an attempt by a dirty old man to take his youngish girlfriend out of the country has turned into something far worse. it seems like our esteemed MP was involved in human trafficking kudos to the BJP for having the courage to suspend him. And that too so very promptly. After their inexcusable response to the Rahul Mahajan fiasco, and the Sidhu homicide — this helps put them back on the road to redemption - at least vis-a-vis ‘integrity’ is concerned.

Sphere: Related Content

Tags: , , ,

14
Mar

Degrees of Corruption

   Posted by: gargi    in India, Politics

India is perceived as the 5th most corrupt nation in Asia, accoring to a survey. I am sure that the political and business class is making serious attempts to ensure that we are top of the list.

Sphere: Related Content

Tags: , , ,

12
Mar

What could Mr.Vajpayee have Meant?

   Posted by: gargi    in India, Politics

George Fernandes, ‘honourable’ minister for Defence in the NDA administration claims that he was prevented from investigating Bofors by the then PM, Atal Behari Vajpayee. Now he tells us that it was a joke

He did ask me not to rake up the issue… But it was all said in a very light-hearted manner. And you know about Atalji… He does make such remarks,”

(aside - can we consider Ajit’s line - "usse liquid oxygen mein dubado…." to be said in a very light hearted manner ) So what could the then PM have meant:

  • Option 1 - Don’t investigate Bofors’ because there is nothing to investigate. It was all smoke without fire.
  • Option 2 - Don’t investigate Bofor’s because if you do the Congress will investigate coffins, telecom licenses etal.
  • Option 3 - Don’t Investigate Bofor’s because everything that was made in Bofor’s is part of the political parties’ mutual fund, and it pays for all our retirement benefits.
  • Option 4 - Vajpayee was joking when he said that don’t investigate it

If i had to choose one option of these four, then option 1 to 3 will be top of my list. Somehow, i find it difficult that the BJP which has had such an anti-Sonia policy, would give up the chance to investigate Bofors. And, I doubt that a man like Atal Behari Vajpayee - would joke about not investigating something like this. Fernandes trying to clarify his ‘Vajpayee told me not to investigate Bofors’ statement, digs him self further in :

He was telling me not to take any decision on whether to go ahead with the purchase (of the Bofors guns) and whether the money paid for them should be got back or any such issue, since no decision had been taken (by the party). As is normal for Vajpayeeji, he may have expressed it in a joking manner, saying ‘Don’t touch the file’,” said Fernandes on Sunday

I am not sure what is worse from the POV of the Indian citizen — a bunch of elected individuals deciding to return money without going through due process, or a Political Party taking a decision - on whether or not to buy guns - that should be taken by the Executive, or the fact that the PM jokingly tells one of his senior ministers’ not to investigate the biggest bribery scandal in the last 3 decades. Is it just me, or does it seem that the entire political establishment is trying to cover this and all other corruption scandals up!!

Sphere: Related Content

Tags: , , , , , , ,

22
Dec

Inconsiderate of Mamta ….

   Posted by: gargi    in And Finally ..., India, Politics

…. feels the Great Bong, to postpone the strike just before Christmas. And he offers suggestions on how she can make reparations.

The situation can only be salvaged if the strike be postponed to 26th and 27th which in hindsight may be even better because then Kolkatans, in addition to having five uninterrupted days of leisure, will also be able to watch comeback kid Dada bat in South Africa for the Boxing Day Test.

And the rest of the post continues in the same vein. Truly funny. Anyone get the feeling that Mamta is increasingly resembling Raju from Guide. Somebody please, please feed her!! aside: getting such opposing forces like the CPI, BJP, Mamta Banerjee, Arundati Roy and Medha Patkar together on the same platform is the best way to ruin the credibility of a protest movement!

Technorati Tags: , ,

Sphere: Related Content

Tags: , , ,

9
Aug

Rules of Work Life

   Posted by: gargi    in India, Politics

One of the key rules of working life is that you better mark your attendance. If you don’t regularyturn up for work, a) your don’t get paid, and if your absence is chronic, b) you get sacked It is some thing that all of us live with, and accept as part of the deal. So why is it any different from Parliamentarians? What gives them the right not to turn up to work? After all we - the tax payer - are paying them well, and on time, and with full benefits. So if they don’t turn up shouldn’t they not be paid, and then if their behaviour continues, shouldn’t they be sacked? Let’s please start with Mr.Govinda - missing Parliamentarian from the constituency nextdoor. The next is Mr.Dharmendra - who by his own wife’s accord does not belong in Parliament. And then let’s start working our way down the BJP ranks - no work no pay and the sack. If we - the people - end up dismissing even 5 of our honourable representatives for not doing their job - the rest will hopefully wake up and start doing theirs.

Sphere: Related Content

Tags: , ,

17
Jul

And Justice for All?

   Posted by: gargi    in India

A couple of years ago to almost the day , a young lady called Manaroma Devi was picked up by the armed forces, under the extremely repressive Armed Forces Special Powers Act (AFSPA). The state was Manipur, the armed forces was a detatchment of Assam Rifles and with a few hours Manorama Devi’s raped, tortured and bullet ridden dead body was recovered. Two hears since her death - there is no justice for her family. All one has is a glib statement that she belonged to a paramilitary organisation (not proven) , and a one man judicial committee that led the probe into her death. Last year this time, in another part of the world, a young plumber called Jean Charles de Menezes was shot dead by the London Metropolitan police who suspected that he was a terrorist. And almost to the date that he was killed the Police chief in London has decided not to charge any policeman with the killing. And then there are the scores of nameless people caught in the last 15 or so years, across the world, under the suspicion of being terrorists. No trial, no sentance, no closure. We don’t know if the guys there are guilty, innocent or a smoke screen. They are almost in limbo land. Maybe, there needs to be? a slightly more fast tracked legal system to deal with this sort of thing. A panel of judges, a team of investigators, more public accountabilty. After all, if the purpose of all this is to tell society at large ‘don’t worry the guilty will be punished, the innocent protected, and the average citizen will walk safe’ then systems across the world are failing. Unless systems across the world get geared for delivering justice, i really don’t see any abatement of terror. If i was the family of Manorama Devi or John Menzes - i am sure that by now i would be burning with rage at the system that bereaved me and showed me no justice. Delhi riots, Gujarat riots, Godhra train burning, Bombay Blasts, Nelli Massacre, Diwali Blasts ……. all of this have one thing in common - justice is yet to be delivered. The System may have some idiot foot soldier in custody confessing to the crime, but where are the big wigs brought to trial (forget trial, where are they even charged). Succor for the vicitms, punishment for the guilty, a sense of security, and justice for all - is this really too much to ask of the modern Republic? other reading: PUCL’s analysis on the AFPSA - here, A collection on the Gujarat Riots - here? sadly, there is nothing on Nellie apart from statistics !

Technorati Tags: , ,

Sphere: Related Content

Tags: , , , , , , , ,